Tips

Medical dictation app or AI scribe?

A dictation app types what you say. An AI scribe drafts the note from the visit, for you to check line by line. What each one does, when dictation is still the better tool, and how to try a scribe on your own visits.

Scott Kohlhepp, DO

Scott Kohlhepp, DO

Founder & CEO

5 min read

In this article

A dictation app types what you say; an AI scribe drafts the note you can check line by line. That's the whole choice. With dictation you still compose the note, out loud instead of on a keyboard. With a scribe you review a draft built from the visit. If most of your notes come from a conversation with a patient and you're finishing them after clinic, a scribe is built for that. If your notes are short, structured and already in your head, a good dictation app may be all you need.

What a dictation app does

Dictation is speech to text. You talk, it types, and what lands on the page is what you said, in the order you said it. Medical dictation apps add a vocabulary that knows drug names and anatomy, and some let you set up shortcuts or move between fields by voice.

What it doesn't do is decide anything. It won't pull the history out of a conversation, sort what you said into the right sections, or notice that you named a medication without a dose. You're still the author of every sentence. That's its real strength: nothing appears in the note that you didn't say. It's also the cost. You still have to write the note, usually after the patient has left, from memory or a few scribbled words.

What an AI scribe adds

An AI scribe works from the visit itself. It listens to the conversation between you and the patient and drafts the note: the history turned into clinical language, the exam you called out, and your assessment and plan. You stop composing and start reviewing.

That changes the question you ask of the note. With dictation you ask whether it typed what you said. With a scribe you ask where each line came from. A draft built from a messy conversation can fill a gap with what a note like this usually says, so your review is only as good as your ability to trace each sentence back. Our post on how to check an AI scribe note for something nobody said goes through where to look first.

So when you compare scribes, look at how the review works, not only at how the draft reads:

  • Can you check a line against its source? Each sentence should point back to the moment in the visit, the prior note or the chart item it came from.
  • What does it do on its own? A scribe should prepare things for you to approve, not act for you.
  • What happens after the trial? Know the price, and what happens to your notes if you stop, before you start.

When dictation is still the right tool

A scribe isn't always the better choice. Dictation still wins in a few places:

  • You already know exactly what the note says. A procedure note, a short addendum or a result you're documenting after a phone call is often easier to say yourself than to review as a draft.
  • There's no conversation to capture. A scribe is built to turn a visit into a note. If the visit is over and you're writing from memory, you're dictating either way.
  • The patient doesn't want to be recorded. A scribe records the visit, so it needs the patient's agreement, and some patients will say no. Dictating your own summary afterward records only you. Our guide to patient consent for ambient recording covers how to ask.
  • The note is mostly your own reasoning. If the value is in how you think through a case rather than what was said in the room, saying it yourself keeps it in your words.

If most of your day looks like that list, a good dictation app is the honest answer. If most of your day is visits where the history comes out in conversation, a scribe takes the writing off your plate and leaves you the checking.

How Scribeable handles the check

We make Scribeable, so weigh this section accordingly. Each sentence in a Scribeable note links back to where it came from: a sentence in the visit recording, a prior note or consultation, or an item in the chart. You can open that source and check the line. That's in the web cockpit and in Threads on iPhone. It doesn't make the note right on its own, and you still read it before you sign. What changes is that checking a line is a click, not a search through a transcript.

Scribeable also leaves the decisions with you. Scribeable prepares drafts and note changes, but never prescribes, sends anything to a pharmacy, signs a note or deletes anything on its own. If you're used to dictation, where nothing happens unless you say it, that part will feel familiar.

Pro is $79 a month, or $790 a year, with unlimited notes. The overview for physicians shows the rest of what it does, and our page on ambient clinical documentation explains how a scribe works from the visit in more detail.

Try it on your own visits

The way to know which tool fits is to use a scribe on a normal clinic day. Every new account gets a 14-day Pro trial, no credit card required: everything in Pro, including Rounding (fair use applies), for up to 150 notes during the trial. To keep Pro after day 14 you subscribe ($79 a month on the web plus applicable tax, or $79.99 a month through Apple in the iOS app). If you don't, nothing is charged and the account moves to the Free plan once you add your NPI (until then it is read-only), with every note kept. Pricing has the details.

Start your 14-day Pro trial.

Try Scribeable on your next clinic day.

Record the visit, then review and edit the note Scribeable writes.

14-day Pro trial, no credit card required. Everything in Pro, including Rounding, for up to 150 notes. To keep Pro after day 14, subscribe for $79/month plus applicable tax. If you don't, nothing is charged and your account moves to the Free plan once you add your NPI (until then it is read-only), with every note kept.

Keep reading

More in Tips →

On scribeable.ai